In the world of software development, we've all been there: deep into technical details, trying to implement a solution that quickly feels too complex and frustrating. This common scenario is often a symptom of a deeper issue known as the XY problem.

The XY problem occurs when we ask for help with our attempted solution (Y) instead of the actual problem we're trying to solve (X). This misdirected focus can lead to a cascade of issues, including:

• Wasted Time and Effort: Developers and teams can spend hours, or even days, struggling with a complex solution for a problem that could be solved more simply.
• Suboptimal Solutions: By fixating on a specific implementation, we might miss a more elegant, efficient, and maintainable solution that addresses the root cause. 
• Technical Debt: Custom, convoluted solutions are often difficult to maintain and upgrade, leading to long-term technical debt.

From "How" to "Why"

The key to avoiding the XY problem is to shift our focus from "how" to "why." Instead of immediately jumping into implementation details, we should first ask:

• What is the underlying business need?
• What is the user trying to achieve?
• Why is the current approach not working?

By asking these "why" questions, we can uncover the true problem (X) and open the door to a wider range of potential solutions.

Pega Constellation: A Prescriptive Approach

This is where Pega's Constellation design system comes in. Constellation is a modern, UI architecture that emphasizes configuration over customization.  Its "prescriptive design" provides a set of pre-built components, patterns, and templates that guide developers toward best-practice solutions. This prescriptive nature is a powerful tool for uncovering and preventing XY problems.

Constellation's design system acts as a set of "guardrails" that keep development on the right track. Here's how it helps:

A Practical Example

Let's assume a developer is tasked with creating a new screen for a customer service application. Their proposed solution (Y) is a complex, custom-built screen with a many fields and buttons. They spend days trying to build this screen, running into technical hurdles and creating a maintenance nightmare.With Pega Constellation, the conversation would be different. The developer would be encouraged to use pre-built views and patterns and explore what is offered out of the box. This would naturally lead to questions like:

• "Why does the user need to see all of this information at once?"
• "What is the most critical information for the user to complete their task?"
• "Can we use a standard list-detail pattern to simplify the UI?"

Through this process, the team might discover that the real problem (X) is that users need a quick, at-a-glance summary of a customer's recent cases rather than another messy dashboard.

Embrace the "Why"

The XY problem is a common pitfall in software development, but it's one that can be avoided. By embracing a "why"-first approach and leveraging the power of a prescriptive design system like Pega Constellation, we can build better, more efficient, and more maintainable applications. The next time you find yourself struggling with a complex technical problem, take a step back and ask yourself: "What is the real problem I'm trying to solve?"  “Can I achieve business requirements with a simpler solution?”. You might be surprised at the simplicity of the answer.

Curious to read your opinion on the subject, and how you handle it.

Constellation 101 Series

Enjoyed this article? See more similar articles in Constellation 101 series.